In the early 1990s, a series of unsolved killings of women, many involved in prostitution and drug use, unsettled communities around New Orleans. Bodies turned up in remote canals, swamps, and roadside areas. One of those cases led to the arrest and conviction of a former taxi driver named Russell Ellwood.
This article examines the investigation into the death of Cheryl Lewis, the 1999 trial in Lafayette, the dropped charges involving Delores Mack, and the 2001 appellate decision that upheld Ellwood’s life sentence. It draws on court records, contemporary reporting, and the work of the multi-agency task force that pursued links among the cases. The goal is a clear, factual account for readers interested in Louisiana criminal history and the challenges of building cases on circumstantial evidence.
Background on Russell Ellwood
Russell Ellwood grew up in Massillon, Ohio, and later moved to the New Orleans area. He worked for periods as a freelance photographer and as a taxi driver. By the 1990s he lived an unsettled life marked by drug use and frequent moves. He had no long-term residence and associated with people involved in street-level drug activity and prostitution.
Ellwood kept detailed records of his daily movements, a habit that later factored into both the investigation and his defense. Authorities described him as a loner. He had prior contacts with law enforcement over drug and traffic matters but no prior murder convictions.
The Murder of Cheryl Lewis and Discovery of the Body
Cheryl Lewis, 30, of Bridge City, was reported missing by her mother, Lillian Lewis, on February 2, 1993. She had last been seen after attending a family birthday gathering. Family members noted she left an uncashed SSI check behind, which raised concern.
On February 21, 1993, a father and son crawfishing near Louisiana Highway 3160 in Hahnville, St. Charles Parish, found a nude body of an African-American woman floating face-down in a canal. Fingerprints identified her as Cheryl Lewis. An autopsy determined the cause of death as drowning. Toxicology showed cocaine and amphetamines in her system. Examiners concluded she was alive but unconscious when she entered the water. The estimated time of death fell between February 1 and February 3, 1993.
The next day, February 22, the body of Delores Mack, 39 or 40, of Metairie, was found roughly 800 feet away in the same canal area. Mack, a post-operative transsexual, had been strangled and suffocated. Cocaine was also present in her system. The proximity of the two discoveries quickly drew investigative attention.
Early Investigation and the Traffic Stop
Nearly one year later, in early 1994, two off-duty St. Charles Parish deputies came upon a vehicle parked at night on the same desolate stretch of highway near the discovery site. The driver, partially undressed, identified himself with a Louisiana license as Russell Ellwood. He told the deputies he had stopped to change the oil and brakes on his taxi. A search of the vehicle turned up no oil, filters, tools, or lighting that would have made such repairs practical in the dark.
The stop was logged. When a multi-jurisdictional serial crime task force later reviewed locations of similar unsolved cases, St. Charles Parish deputies flagged the earlier contact with Ellwood. That information placed him on the task force radar.
Formation of the New Orleans Serial Killer Task Force
Between 1991 and 1996, authorities recovered the bodies of roughly two dozen women, most of them Black, many with histories of prostitution or drug use, in swampy or remote areas stretching from Algiers through Jefferson, St. Charles, and neighboring parishes. Causes of death included strangulation, drowning, and apparent drug overdoses. Some victims were transsexual.
In 1995 a multi-agency New Orleans serial killer task force formed, drawing personnel from local sheriff’s offices, the New Orleans Police Department, and the FBI. Investigators explored the possibility of one or more serial offenders. Ellwood emerged as a person of interest because of his occupation, his presence near one of the dump sites, and later statements attributed to him.
Interviews, Statements, and Arrest
In July 1997, task force members, including Jefferson Parish officers, traveled to Sebring, Florida, where Ellwood was living with his father. After being advised of his rights, he gave recorded statements over several days. He acknowledged extensive involvement with prostitutes, heavy drug use, and a preference for Black women.
Shortly afterward Ellwood was arrested in Florida on a cocaine charge and held for about 85 days. During that time, fellow inmates later testified that he described taking prostitutes to remote areas, overdosing them, choking them, and removing their bodies from his taxi. One inmate, Stan Hill, provided a detailed account. Ellwood later admitted to investigators that he had made statements of that nature to Hill.
After release on the Florida charge, Ellwood moved to Ohio. Task force members interviewed him again there, this time with a Cincinnati homicide detective present. In one conversation Ellwood allegedly acknowledged taking a Black woman, driving her down a road, and putting her in the water. He refused to allow that particular statement to be recorded and later denied making it.
In January 1998 Ellwood returned voluntarily to Louisiana. He was arrested and charged with the second-degree murders of both Cheryl Lewis and Delores Mack. A St. Charles Parish grand jury later indicted him on those counts and an additional perjury count related to grand-jury testimony.
Dropped Charges in the Delores Mack Case
Prosecutors eventually determined that Ellwood had a verifiable alibi placing him in Ohio around the time of Delores Mack’s death. On March 2, 1999, the state entered a nolle prosequi on the Mack count. The indictment was amended to focus solely on the murder of Cheryl Lewis, alleged to have occurred on or between January 31 and February 9, 1993.
Defense attorneys and some observers argued that the collapse of the Mack charge undermined the overall case. Prosecutors maintained that the remaining evidence against Ellwood for Lewis’s death was still sufficient.
Change of Venue and the 1999 Trial in Lafayette
Extensive pretrial publicity in St. Charles Parish prompted the defense to seek a change of venue. The trial court granted the motion, moving the case to Lafayette.
Trial began on June 8, 1999, and lasted three days. The prosecution presented a circumstantial case. Three witnesses testified they had seen Lewis with or near Ellwood shortly before her disappearance. One acquaintance described an encounter in which Lewis sought drugs and Ellwood drove past in his vehicle.
Inmates testified about statements Ellwood made while incarcerated in Florida. A prostitute testified that Ellwood had once become angry and told her, in substance, that he killed women like her. The state also highlighted Ellwood’s unexplained presence at the remote Hahnville location a year after the bodies were found.
The defense challenged the reliability of the jailhouse witnesses and the overall lack of physical evidence linking Ellwood to the canal or to Lewis’s body. No DNA, fingerprints, or other forensic material tied him directly to the crime scene.
On June 11, 1999, the jury returned a unanimous verdict of guilty of second-degree murder.
Sentencing and the Life Term
On August 17, 1999, the court sentenced Russell Ellwood to life imprisonment at hard labor without benefit of parole, probation, or suspension of sentence. The sentence was the mandatory term under Louisiana law for second-degree murder.
Appellate Review: State v. Ellwood (2001)
Ellwood appealed to the Louisiana Fifth Circuit Court of Appeal. The principal assignment of error challenged the sufficiency of the evidence. He argued that the state’s case rested entirely on unreliable circumstantial proof and that the witnesses, particularly the inmates and individuals with criminal histories, lacked credibility.
In a decision issued February 28, 2001 (State v. Ellwood, 783 So.2d 423), the Fifth Circuit affirmed the conviction. Applying the Jackson v. Virginia standard, the court held that a rational trier of fact, viewing the evidence in the light most favorable to the prosecution, could have found the essential elements of second-degree murder beyond a reasonable doubt.
The court noted that specific intent to kill or inflict great bodily harm can be inferred from circumstances and that, under Louisiana’s circumstantial-evidence rule, every reasonable hypothesis of innocence must be excluded. The combination of eyewitness sightings of Ellwood with Lewis, his presence at the dump site a year later under suspicious circumstances, and the statements he made to inmates and investigators was deemed sufficient. Credibility determinations were left to the jury.
The appellate court found no reversible error and remanded only for a technical correction regarding notice of the post-conviction relief period.
Controversies Surrounding the Investigation
The broader task-force investigation drew criticism. The FBI at one point distanced itself and examined allegations that a task-force leader had mishandled or destroyed receipts that might have supported an alibi. A former girlfriend’s claim that Ellwood had shown her the bodies was contested by the defense as coached. Ellwood filed a federal civil-rights lawsuit asserting that investigators had fabricated or coerced statements.
Despite the intensity of the multi-agency effort, Ellwood was the only person charged and convicted in connection with the series of deaths. Other suspects, including a former New Orleans police officer, were investigated but not prosecuted for the bulk of the cases. Many of the 1991–1996 homicides remain officially unsolved. Investigators have long suggested that more than one offender may have been responsible.
Key Legal Takeaways from the Case
The Ellwood prosecution illustrates several recurring features of Louisiana criminal practice in the late 1990s:
- Second-degree murder under La. R.S. 14:30.1 requires proof of specific intent to kill or to inflict great bodily harm.
- Circumstantial evidence can support a conviction when it excludes every reasonable hypothesis of innocence.
- Jailhouse informant testimony is admissible but subject to rigorous credibility testing by the jury.
- Change-of-venue motions are granted when pretrial publicity creates a substantial likelihood of prejudice.
- Appellate courts give strong deference to jury findings on witness credibility and will not re-weigh evidence under the Jackson standard.
The case also highlights the practical difficulties of investigating series of deaths involving transient victims, delayed discovery of bodies, and limited forensic technology available at the time.
Conclusion
Russell Ellwood’s 1999 conviction for the second-degree murder of Cheryl Lewis closed one chapter in a larger, still-unresolved set of New Orleans-area killings. The trial, held in Lafayette after a venue change, rested on a carefully constructed circumstantial case that survived appellate scrutiny in 2001. The dropped charge involving Delores Mack and the controversies surrounding task-force methods remain part of the historical record.
For true-crime researchers, criminology students, and those following Louisiana legal history, the Ellwood matter offers a detailed study of how investigators link a suspect to a single homicide amid a broader pattern of unsolved deaths. Readers seeking primary materials should consult the published appellate opinion and contemporary reporting from St. Charles and Lafayette Parish sources.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who was Russell Ellwood?
Russell Ellwood was a former New Orleans taxi driver from Ohio who became a suspect in a series of 1990s Louisiana homicides. He was convicted in 1999 of the second-degree murder of Cheryl Lewis and sentenced to life imprisonment.
What happened to Cheryl Lewis?
Cheryl Lewis, 30, disappeared in early February 1993. Her nude body was found on February 21, 1993, in a canal off Louisiana Highway 3160 near Hahnville. The cause of death was drowning while she was unconscious; cocaine and amphetamines were present in her system.
Why were the Delores Mack charges dropped?
Prosecutors determined Ellwood had a valid alibi placing him in Ohio at the relevant time. The state entered a nolle prosequi on the Mack count in March 1999 and proceeded only on the Lewis charge.
Where was the trial held and why?
The trial was moved from St. Charles Parish to Lafayette because of extensive pretrial publicity that risked prejudicing a local jury.
What was the outcome of the appeal?
In State v. Ellwood, 783 So.2d 423 (La. App. 5 Cir. 2001), the Louisiana Fifth Circuit Court of Appeal affirmed the conviction, finding the circumstantial evidence sufficient under the Jackson standard.
Was Ellwood linked to other murders?
He was investigated as a suspect in additional cases among the roughly two dozen deaths examined by the serial-crime task force, but he was charged and convicted only in the Cheryl Lewis case. Many of the other homicides remain unsolved.
What sentence did Ellwood receive?
On August 17, 1999, he was sentenced to life imprisonment at hard labor without benefit of parole, probation, or suspension of sentence.
You May Also Like: A Comprehensive Guide to ADCO Legal Services Offered for Businesses and Individuals

One Comment on “Russell Ellwood: Inside the 1999 Louisiana Murder Trial”